A fresh tomato and mozzarella pizza on an oak table beside a village pizzeria window in soft autumn daylight.

Where to Get Pizza in Newton, Village by Village

On its busiest night, the small kitchen at Jinny's Pizzeria on Centre Street has sent out 380 pizzas. Dave Punch, who co-owns it with Lydia Reichert, told The Boston Globe in October that the shop "can do a pizza a minute, every minute, for four hours straight," and that Jinny's earns more than his other restaurants, Sycamore and Little Big Diner. Jinny's seats 18 people. Most of its pizzas leave the building through online orders.

Those numbers explain a lot about how Newton eats. Chefs with fine-dining résumés now treat pizza as the reliable part of their business. In the same villages, family counters have been making pies since the 1960s, '70s and '80s. Newton has both kinds of shop, often a few blocks apart, so the city has more serious pizza than its size would suggest. This guide goes through the shops village by village, from the oldest counter to the newest oven, in time for the takeout-heavy nights around Thanksgiving.

Why chefs are opening pizzerias, starting on Centre Street

The Globe article, titled "Dough makes dough" after one of Punch's lines, is about Boston-area chefs leaving tasting menus for pizza. Newton turns up in it three times. Punch's argument is mostly about labor. Sycamore needs "five, six, seven guys to pull off a night," while Jinny's sells about $20 pies from one small kitchen. He also says the ingredients cost less and the work is "a very trainable business."

For someone ordering in Newton Centre, this means Jinny's at 1231 Centre St. is built for volume, and the pies hold up well on the way home. The oven is wood-fired and runs at 700 degrees. A Newton Beacon profile adds some local detail. The turquoise oven is named Dottie McLovin'. The restaurant is named for Reichert's grandmother. Each spring Jinny's makes a ramp pizza during the short wild-onion season, and in warm weather it opens a front patio. The same profile says the margherita and the pepperoni are the regulars' favorites, and that the North End Oil dip comes with olive oil, chili flakes, pecorino and herbs.

Newtonville has four pizza kitchens within a few blocks

Newtonville shows the overlap most clearly. Four kitchens within a short walk of the Walnut Street and Washington Street intersection make pizza four different ways.

Newtonville Pizza at 322 Walnut St. is the oldest. It describes itself as locally owned and serving the neighborhood since 1974. Two doors up, OTTO at 344 Walnut St. opened in 2024 in the former Donut Villa space. Farther down Walnut, MIDA at 261 Walnut St. has had pizzas on its menu since chef Douglass Williams opened the Newton location in June 2021. In the Globe article, Williams says he still hopes to open a small standalone pizza shop someday.

The fourth kitchen is da LaPosta at 825 Washington St., the most chef-driven of the group. Mario LaPosta trained as a pizza maker in Italy during college, cooked at Lupa and Babbo, and now has his own flour line with Central Milling, a Utah company. He told the Globe he is experimenting with pies that are part Roman and part Neapolitan, aiming for a crust between soft and crackery, with toppings like local corn, cherry tomatoes and fresh figs. Eater Boston calls the pizza Neapolitan-style and lists da LaPosta among Newton's best restaurants. The restaurant takes reservations and has an aperitivo hour from 4 to 6 p.m., Thursday through Saturday.

That puts a 1974 counter, a 2024 arrival, and two chef-owned dining rooms within a few blocks of each other, and each one is built for a different kind of night.

The counters that came first

The newer ovens get the coverage, but some of Newton's pizza shops are older than most of the restaurants around them.

Tom's Pizza & Sandwich Shop at 423 Lexington St. in Auburndale Square says it has been family-owned and operated since 1964. According to its own history, Tom's opened with about 20 menu items, picnic tables, a grill and a gas oven. Its current owner is Fred Kanavos. Today the menu has an original pan pie, a Detroit-style pie and a Sicilian square. The Globe's October survey lists Detroit pies among the regional styles that recently "joined the chat" in Boston-area pizza, and in Auburndale one is already on the menu at a counter that has been around for six decades.

In Nonantum, D&A House of Pizza at 308 Watertown St. says it is family-owned and has served pizza since 1982.

Over in West Newton, West Newton Pizza at 1288 Washington St. takes pickup and delivery orders through its own site, and Sweet Tomatoes is just across Washington Street at 1279. Sweet Tomatoes has a second shop at 47 Langley Rd. in Newton Centre.

A new license at 845 Beacon Street

The block of Beacon Street east of Newton Centre has several pizza shops close together. Bill's Pizzeria is at 753 Beacon St. A little farther east, 845 Beacon St. got some citywide attention in February, when the Newton Beacon reported that Dave Portnoy had reviewed Newton Centre Town Pizza on his One Bite channel. He scored it 6.6 out of 10 and described the pie as falling between a bar pie and a conventional whole pie. The same article names Bill's, Jinny's, Sweet Tomatoes and Frank Pepe as places residents praise.

The same address has a new name on file. On September 15, 2026, Newton's Board of License Commissioners voted 3–0 to approve a license for Newton House Pizza at 845 Beacon St., according to the meeting minutes. The plan filed for the shop lists 18 seats, with hours of 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day.

Every village has at least one pizza shop

The Globe's "Dough makes dough" piece ends with a chef on Beacon Hill, in Boston, who isn't worried about too many pizzerias opening: "Really good pizza brings more people into the neighborhood." Newton's version of that is spread across its villages. Several of them have both a chef-run oven and a long-running counter, and nearly every village center has at least one shop. The list below comes from the city's 2026 license renewals and the shops' own sites.

Village Shop Address Worth knowing
Auburndale Tom's Pizza & Sandwich Shop 423 Lexington St. Family business since 1964; pan, Detroit and Sicilian square
Nonantum D&A House of Pizza 308 Watertown St. Family-owned, pizza since 1982
Newtonville Newtonville Pizza 322 Walnut St. Locally owned since 1974
Newtonville OTTO 344 Walnut St. Opened 2024 in the former Donut Villa space
Newtonville MIDA 261 Walnut St. Pizzas on the menu at Douglass Williams's restaurant
Newtonville da LaPosta 825 Washington St. Wood-fired, naturally leavened dough
West Newton West Newton Pizza 1288 Washington St. Pickup and delivery through its own site
West Newton Sweet Tomatoes 1279 Washington St. Second shop on Langley Road
Newton Centre Jinny's Pizzeria 1231 Centre St. 700-degree wood-fired oven, 18 seats
Newton Centre Bill's Pizzeria 753 Beacon St. One of the Beacon Street shops
Newton Centre Sweet Tomatoes 47 Langley Rd. Near the Langley Road shops
Newton Highlands Four Corners Pizza 1138–1142 Beacon St. At the Four Corners intersection
Waban Stone L'Oven Pizza Co. 1649 Beacon St. Individually owned and operated
Upper Falls Brickfire Pizza Co. 1214 Chestnut St. House-made sauce and dough
Newton Corner Max & Leo's 325 Washington St. Coal-fired at 900 degrees, about a two-minute cook
Newton Corner area C&N Pizza 437 Centre St. New license approved January 2026
Chestnut Hill Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana 199 Boylston St. Newton-side outpost of the New Haven name

The two coal and wood ovens at either end of the city cook at very different speeds. Max & Leo's says its 900-degree coal oven finishes a pie in about two minutes. That makes it a quick stop for anyone heading home through Newton Corner. Jinny's pace on a busy night is the pizza-a-minute rate Punch described to the Globe. Brickfire in Upper Falls and Stone L'Oven in Waban are the local shops for those two villages. Brickfire advertises house-made sauce and dough. Stone L'Oven says its Newton location is individually owned and operated.

For a household planning the busy nights around Thanksgiving, Newton's pizza map means a choice of style is rarely more than a village away. One house might order a Sicilian square from Tom's for the cousins, while another books a table at da LaPosta for a quieter dinner the night before.

Dan Demeo grew up in Newton, and he still marks the villages by their old counters and newer ovens. If you've been wondering what your home is worth in a village with your favorite pizza place around the corner, the Demeo Team can give you a free home valuation based on the streets you know.

Partner With Our Expert Team

We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth.

Follow Me on Instagram